Reddit Report, 7/6-12: House rules, Sliding sleeves & Blind Hive

(The Reddit Report is a weekly feature, published every Saturday.)

A lot of great ideas for game variations and house rules. I’m loving this week’s threads!

SUGGESTIONS

Best House Rules?
submitted by PM_me_your_toaster

This thread was posted on Reddit just a day after a thread called Worst House Rules. Everybody has their own House Rule horror stories that they’d rather forget. But only a few hardy souls relish the chance to tweak a popular game.

Don’t freak out: the best House Rules don’t change the game, but they do make playing more Fun.

Surprisingly, there were almost 250 comments in response, with a cornucopia of great ideas. I’m a huge fan of House Rules, so I saved the page and I’m going to catalogue them for future use.

Among my favorites:

Ticket to Ride: Don’t keep score during the game, just at the end. Rather than making players discouraged if they fall behind, everyone’s keeping a watchful eye on what others have played. (heathtree)

Carcassone: Pick up your next tile at the end of your turn instead of the beginning of the next one. Cuts down on the Analysis Paralysis. (alexwilson)

Jaipur: To break this game’s frequent ties, the panda-hide camel is counted as 1.01 camels. (sgol)

WSIG (WHAT SHOULD I GET?)

What is a Good Alternative to Diplomacy?
submitted by pillowwolf

The OP is looking for a shorter alternative to a great – but loooong – game.

Among the 40-some suggestions: Cosmic Encounter, Dune, Article 27, Lifeboat, Imperial, and Archipelago. The Game of Thrones Board Game is probably the most like Diplomacy, but it can also take just as long.

Read the thread to learn why these alternatives are worth a look.

IDEAS?

Card sleeves that don’t slide when stacked
submitted by Veri7as

The OP’s solution was to use Matte sleeves, but they only came in one size and, as one commenter pointed out, make it harder to read fine print.

Best suggestion came from a couple of the 13 commenters and it’s relatively simple:

Stack heavy books on top of a stack of cards.

Second best idea was to Shuffle them a lot to wear the slippery gloss off them. Several comments noted that the slipperiness wears off with use.

ETIQUETTE

An apology to board gamers
submitted by elscorchoOoOoOo

OP’s apology was specifically in connection with his card shuffling, as he always falls back on the old ‘bridge’ shuffle.

It led to other discussions (over 135 comments total) of card game etiquette, including the problem some players have with mindlessly damaging a card while deciding whether to play it.

VARIANTS

Blind hive
submitted by CodeAndKnives

Submitted by OP as a blind/randomizing variant for experienced players. Further discussion showed that CAK’s variant would be best utilized when an experienced player is facing a new player. It’s basically a handicapping option, leveling the playing field a little. Check it out! 14 commenters did.

Are you a Redditor, too? Have I missed something interesting from Reddit that you want to share? Please let us know in the Comments!

(Reddit logo is in the Public Domain.)
  • Drew is a contributor to the Board Gamers Anonymous podcast. He's a curator by nature, compulsively reading and obsessively organizing what he's read. He's also been a gamer since the age of 3, which means he's been playing board games for... let's just say more than 40 years, and leave it at that...

  • Show Comments

You May Also Like

Advice for New Board Gamers

Several days a week, I ask followers on Facebook and Twitter to share their ...

Joining John's Salon (Part 5 of Sitting on 3000 Games)

(NOTE: This is the first part of the full post that I wrote. For ...

Almanac of Games, June 29th: Surviving the Log Cabin Canal

(Almanac of Games is a weekly feature, published every Sunday) It’s Classics Day, as ...

Podcast about Learning Styles on Board Game Design Lab

I was lucky enough to be a guest on the Board Game Design Lab ...

Almanac of Games for July 27: To the Guillotine with King Henry's Aunt!

IT HAPPENED ON THIS DAY… …in 1793, that Maximilien de Robespierre was elected to ...

Zombicide: Green Horde, CMON Kickstarters, and FOMO

CMON is at it again. Zombicide: Green Horde has laid claim to our wallets, ...